Skip to content

PLAT-007: Scenario Expressiveness Gap Tracking

Statement

Shifter shall treat scenario-specific provisioner or runtime end-runs as ACES migration/profile gaps, not as private implementation behavior or new CyberScript semantics. Until ACES parity and cutover gates pass, current CyberScript and CMS scenario paths remain authoritative for production use; new scenario capabilities outside the current CyberScript vocabulary shall be recorded in the ACES migration parity inventory or ACES SDL/profile backlog before the workaround is relied on for event or range production use.

Rationale

The RAES contract is the scenario authoring authority. Shared expressiveness gaps belong in its profile or the typed adapter SDK. Pack-specific implementation belongs in an external adapter, with generic platform contracts and synthetic acceptance fixtures in core.

Traceability

  • DOCUMENTS → GITHUB_ISSUE Brad-Edwards/bigrae#620 (Scenario expressiveness dependency)
  • IMPLEMENTS → POLICY docs/architecture/aces-migration-parity-inventory.yaml (ACES parity inventory: governance block (record-before-production-reliance) and the three PLAT-007 expressiveness-gap rows)
  • IMPLEMENTS → CODE_FILE scripts/adr_guard/adr_guard.py (aces-parity-inventory-row-schema check (ADR-024-R2): closed-set category/surface/next_issue_kind, required fields, unique row ids)
  • IMPLEMENTS → ADR docs/adr/index.yaml (ADR-024-R2 wired to the aces-parity-inventory-row-schema check)
  • IMPLEMENTS → DOCUMENTATION docs/architecture/aces-cyberscript-issue-triage.md (PLAT-007 requirement posture, pointing at the parity inventory governance block)
  • TESTS → TEST scripts/adr_guard/tests/test_adr_guard.py (AcesParityInventoryRowSchemaTests: closed-set membership, required fields, duplicate ids, shrunken required_fields header, and the five fail-closed structural branches)
  • DOCUMENTS → DOCUMENTATION docs/architecture/scenario-expressiveness-gap-tracking-preflight-676.md (Scenario expressiveness gap tracking architecture preflight (#676))
  • IMPLEMENTS → GITHUB_ISSUE Brad-Edwards/bigrae#676 (PLAT-007: Scenario Expressiveness Gap Tracking)